How to Choose the Right Coach: Where Do You Start?
Whether you're in Singapore or anywhere else in the world, choosing the right coach starts with knowing what to look for.
During a sailing trip in Portugal this summer, I met a British woman who was living in California.
She was travelling with her mother, while I was there with my husband and daughter. We happened to sit next to each other, and throughout the trip, the conversation flowed naturally.
As we talked about our lives, backgrounds and experiences, the subject of our professions came up.
When she discovered that I was a professional coach, she shared something that caught my attention.
"I've always been curious about coaching, but I wouldn't really know where to start or how to choose a coach."
Her comment stayed with me.
As a professional coach, I spend a lot of time explaining what coaching can help people achieve. But perhaps we sometimes forget that, for someone who has never experienced coaching, even knowing where to begin can feel confusing.
There are life coaches, career coaches, executive coaches, leadership coaches, performance coaches and many more.
How do you know which one you need? How do you assess their qualifications? And most importantly, how do you find someone you can trust?
Choosing a coach shouldn't be a guessing game.
So, inspired by that conversation somewhere along the Portuguese coast, I thought I would share a few practical considerations to help anyone curious about coaching take that first step with greater confidence.

The Confusion Around the Word “Coach”
This is where I started my explanation to her.
Coaching has become increasingly popular in many different environments, but the word itself is used in so many contexts that it can be confusing.
We hear about sports coaches, sales coaches, business coaches, influencers offering coaching services and even mentors calling themselves coaches.
But they don't necessarily offer the same type of support, follow the same professional standards or have the same training.
So, if you're looking for a professional coach to support your personal or professional development, where should you start?
My first recommendation: Check their credentials
I always recommend looking for a coach who holds a credential from the International Coaching Federation (ICF).
Why?
The ICF is one of the longest-established international professional coaching organisations. It provides a recognised framework for professional coaching standards, education, practical experience and ethical conduct.
To earn an ICF credential, a coach must complete specific coaching education, demonstrate practical coaching experience, undergo an assessment of their coaching skills and pass an examination.
What I particularly appreciate is the transparency.
The ICF has three levels of credentials, allowing you to understand the minimum training and coaching experience a professional has demonstrated.
ACC, Associate Certified Coach
At least 60 hours of coaching education and 100 hours of coaching experience.
PCC, Professional Certified Coach
At least 125 hours of coaching education and 500 hours of coaching experience.
MCC, Master Certified Coach
At least 200 hours of coaching education and 2,500 hours of coaching experience.
And the learning doesn't stop once a coach receives their credential.
ICF coaches must renew their credentials every three years, completing continuing professional education to maintain and develop their coaching competencies.
For me, this is an important part of professional coaching. It demonstrates a commitment not only to learning how to coach, but also to continuing to develop as a practitioner.
Of course, credentials alone don't guarantee that a particular coach will be the right person for you. But they provide a useful starting point when you don't know where to begin. Where can you find the right coach?
Start by looking for professional coaches in your region, or explore LinkedIn, where many coaches share articles, insights and reflections about their work.
Pay attention to coaches whose content resonates with you, whose perspectives make you think differently and whose approach seems aligned with what you're looking for.
Once you've identified someone who interests you, check their professional credentials.
If they claim to be ICF credentialed, you can verify their credentials through the official ICF website.
And remember, finding a coach isn't just about qualifications or an impressive professional background. It's also about finding someone you feel comfortable with and can trust.
An introductory conversation is often the best way to discover whether the relationship feels right.
Do you need a life coach, career coach or executive coach?
This is another question that often creates confusion.
An ICF credentialed coach is trained in professional coaching competencies that can be applied across many areas of personal and professional development.
A coach doesn't necessarily need a separate ICF credential to work with someone on career decisions, leadership challenges, confidence or personal development.
So why do coaches describe themselves as life coaches, career coaches, executive coaches or leadership coaches?
There are several reasons.
Some choose a particular area because of their personal interests, professional background or the type of clients they enjoy working with.
Others specialise because they have developed additional knowledge, qualifications or methodologies that are particularly relevant to certain clients.
And, of course, defining a specialisation can also help establish credibility and communicate more clearly whom they work with.
For example, alongside my ICF PCC credential, I chose to develop additional expertise in Emotional Intelligence, becoming certified in EQ-i 2.0 and EQ 360 assessments.
I also bring experience and an understanding of different professional environments, including creative industries, technology, finance and nonprofit organisations.
Over time, my coaching practice has naturally developed in these directions.
However, this doesn't mean I can only coach people working in these industries.
Professional coaching skills are transferable. What changes is the context, the person and the objectives they bring to the conversation.
My Integrated Coaching approach is built on this understanding. Career, leadership, performance and personal life don't exist in separate boxes, and the coaching process needs to consider the whole person.
When choosing a coach, I would therefore encourage you to look beyond their title.
My second recommendation: Find someone you feel comfortable with
Credentials are important, but the relationship you build with your coach is just as important.
You need to feel comfortable with the person and, above all, feel that you can trust them.
Let's face it, sharing personal experiences, doubts, fears or challenges with someone you have just met isn't always easy.
For some people, trust develops naturally during the first conversation. For others, it may take two or three sessions before they feel comfortable enough to open up. And that's perfectly fine.
One important thing to know is that ICF credentialed coaches are bound by the ICF Code of Ethics, which includes professional obligations regarding confidentiality.
This means your coach is expected to protect the information you share during your coaching relationship, within the confidentiality agreement and applicable legal and ethical limits.
It creates an important foundation for trust, allowing you to explore situations that you may not feel comfortable discussing elsewhere.
But why speak to a coach when you can talk to a friend, your spouse or a family member?
This is another question worth exploring.
The people closest to us often know us very well. They care about us, want the best for us and naturally have opinions about what we should or shouldn't do.
But they also have their own expectations, experiences, beliefs and biases.
Sometimes, without even realising it, they may project these onto us.
Think about someone considering a career change.
A spouse might worry about financial security. Parents might encourage them to stay in a stable profession. A friend might suggest following their passion because that's what worked for them.
None of these perspectives is necessarily wrong. They usually come from a place of care.
But are they helping you discover what you really want, or are they influencing your decisions through their own experiences and expectations?
Sometimes, these external expectations can even reinforce limiting beliefs we already hold about ourselves.
This is where professional coaching offers something different.
A coach isn't there to tell you what they would do in your situation or to make decisions for you.
Their role is to listen, ask questions, challenge assumptions and help you explore perspectives you may not have considered.
An ICF coach is trained to remain aware of personal biases and avoid imposing their own beliefs, values or expectations on the client.
The objective is to offer a confidential, non-judgemental space where you can reflect openly, deepen your self-awareness and discover your own answers.
Because ultimately, the decision is yours, and so is the life you will live with it.
Coaching or mentoring: What's the difference?
Another important distinction I explained during our conversation was the difference between coaching and mentoring.
A professional coach isn't there to make you dependent on their advice or to become someone you need to consult every time you face an important decision.
Quite the opposite.
The objective of coaching is to strengthen your ability to think independently, make decisions, adapt to change and build confidence in your own judgement.
A mentor generally takes a different approach.
Mentors share their knowledge, professional experience and lessons learned to help someone navigate situations they may have already encountered themselves.
And mentoring can be extremely valuable, particularly within a professional environment.
I sometimes work with clients who also have mentors, and the combination can work very well.
For example, a senior employee within the same organisation can provide valuable insights into the company's culture, industry, internal processes and career opportunities.
But there is something worth considering.
A mentor's advice is naturally influenced by their own experiences, successes and the environment in which they developed their career.
And the world is changing quickly.
What worked ten or twenty years ago may not necessarily be the best approach today, particularly as technology, artificial intelligence and workplace expectations continue to evolve.
This doesn't make their experience irrelevant, but it is important to recognise that someone else's path to success isn't necessarily the right path for you.
There is also a growing tendency for mentors and managers to incorporate coaching techniques into their conversations.
Asking questions, listening actively and encouraging reflection are certainly useful skills. However, reading books about coaching or adopting a few techniques isn't the same as completing professional coach training and developing the competencies required to practise coaching.
This is where the distinction can sometimes become confusing.
A mentor may move between giving advice and asking coaching-style questions, while a professionally trained coach works within a defined coaching framework, with clear ethical responsibilities and an emphasis on the client's autonomy.
Neither approach is necessarily better.
They serve different purposes, and when their roles are understood, they can complement each other very effectively.
A mentor may help you learn from their experience. A coach helps you develop the awareness, confidence and judgement to create your own.
So, how do you know if you've found the right coach?
Before committing to a coaching programme, I recommend having an introductory conversation.
This is an opportunity to discuss what brings you to coaching, understand the coach's approach and see how comfortable you feel speaking with them.
You don't need to arrive with a perfectly defined objective.
Sometimes, clarifying what you really want is part of the coaching process itself.
Here are a few questions you may wish to ask:
What professional coaching credentials do you hold?
What experience do you have with the challenges I am facing?
How would you describe your coaching approach?
What can I expect from a typical coaching session?
How do you manage confidentiality?
How will we know whether coaching is helping me progress?
Pay attention not only to the answers, but also to how the conversation feels.
Does the coach listen carefully?
Do you feel respected and understood?
Are you being encouraged to reflect, or are you immediately being told what you should do?
A good coaching relationship is a partnership, and you should feel comfortable asking questions before deciding to work together.
The right coach is not necessarily the one with all the answers
Looking back at that conversation in Portugal, I realised how easily someone can remain curious about coaching without ever taking the first step.
Not because they aren't interested, but simply because they don't know what to look for.
My advice is to start with three things:
Check the credentials. Understand the approach. Trust the relationship.
Whether you're considering coaching for your career, leadership development, performance or personal growth, the right coach should help you become more aware, more confident and more capable of navigating your own decisions.
After all, coaching isn't about having someone tell you how to live your life.
It's about developing the clarity and confidence to move forward in a direction that makes sense to you.
At Compass Coaching Singapore, I offer personalised executive, leadership, career and personal development coaching, both in person and online.
As an ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC), with additional certifications in Emotional Intelligence assessments, I work with clients from different professional and cultural backgrounds through an Integrated Coaching approach.
If you've been curious about coaching but aren't sure where to begin, you're welcome to reach out for an introductory conversation.
Warm regards, Celine Foelmli





Comments